(i just read in a newspaper that a woman adopted a baby – a beautiful little girl – and then a few months later, decided that she wanted to ‘return’ the child. i wrote this blog many, many, many months ago, but felt it appropriate to share it again. ken would rather i didn’t ‘share’ it again, so we flipped a coin. HEADS, i won, TAIL between his legs. Welcome to Amy-land!)

It was sort of like an impulse buy. There was a two-week period when I was feeling this overwhelming need to fill a huge void in my life. I wasn’t quite sure what the void in fact was, I just knew that something – something – had to fill it. I remember that morning as if it were yesterday. Ken was reading the newspaper, drinking his hot and steamy cup of coffee, I was deciding on whether to wear the black short sleeve tee-shirt with slacks, or the white short sleeve tee-shirt with slacks. I chose the white. I walked out onto our porch, where Ken seemed so calm and peaceful and I stood there with my hands ever so firmly planted on my hips and said – or rather announced with great determination – yes, I’ve decided, I want to foster a child. Ken nodded, continued reading the Sports page and as he sipped his coffee, caught a glimpse of me over the rim of the cup. “Seriously, Ken, I want to be a mother.” This, a conversation, continuing from the night before.

Let me back track for just a moment. When Ken and I met there were two things that Ken never, ever wanted to do again: one, was get married, and two, was have a child. He had done both, and that was quite enough for him. I too felt when I first met Ken that marriage was a very iffy commitment. I mean, why? So that when you divorce, all the shit that was yours to begin with now has to get tossed into a legal heap and maybe you won’t get the CD’s and the few pieces of furniture you brought to the party to begin with. But a few months after our first date, along with the “I’m never getting married again,” lecture, we found ourselves picking out wedding rings and meeting with Unitarian ministers. We chose both within a week. Okay back to the foster children…

I had this urge, not necessarily to give birth, but to fill what felt like a unyielding emptiness. I am not, I repeat not, a nurturing kind of woman. But there was this need, this urge, this flu like symptom that didn’t seem to go away. I thought maybe instead of adopting a child, we could, for lack of better words, rent one. See if it works. I had heard both very good and very awful stories about foster care, and fostering children. I knew a couple who had brought a foster child into their home and two weeks later felt they were being tortured emotionally. I have friends who had huge success at fostering a child, ending up adopting the little girl, and another one whose child turned out to be the devil doll. But I understood that these children needed to be loved. They needed to be cared for, their place in the world was so fragile, so tentative, so scary.

And I, obviously, had an urge.

I stood there and waited for Ken to give me his blessing. “Sure, fine, you wanna do this, go check it out.” “Wanna come with me?” “Nah. I’m gonna watch football.” Ken thought, right or wrong, that it was like going to the Bide-a-wee, or the Humane Society. This isn’t something Ken cares to do, even though he is a very altruistic kind loving man. I was going to go the Children’s Aid Center and discuss the possibility of he and I becoming Foster Parents and while highly unlikely maybe come home with a happy loving child who Ken could garden with. Or at the very least, watch football with. I am such an optimistic fool.

I go to the Children’s Aid office in our very small town. I am greeted with both a lack of enthusiasm, and much paperwork. Reams and reams of paperwork. I fill out most, call Ken twice (for his social security number which I couldn’t for the life of me remember, along with some financial information) and then I’m Ied to a small empty room with a scattering of very old magazines. I for one believe any and all public spaces should keep up to date magazines. This is a cause I will champion in the future. Nothing worse than old, old news.

A young woman comes into the office. She reminds me of an Amish woman, or a Mormon, wearing a long floral schmata and a very, very bad haircut. It looked like a very, very bad helmet. She says nothing, but gestures for me to follow her. As I walk out of the room with her, I casually mention that they oughta get some up to date magazines.

As an aside, in one of our continual (I am pushy) conversations both that morning, and the night before, Ken tells me that – if in fact I actually go through with this – he would prefer a boy, if in fact there’s a choice, and a boy who can garden, weed, since it’s summertime and if in fact we are going to foster a child for two, three, four weeks than I should take into consideration that it would be great for Ken to have a weeding partner slash buddy. I, of course, would love a girl to go shopping with and go to nail salons with and someone to talk to about Ken’s – her foster father – weeding issues.

I am now led to another room where the Mormon slash Amish woman has a desk. I sit across from her and I look around the room for signs, clues of a life, her life. I see not a photo, or a calendar, or any sign of life, period. In the corner on the radiator what appears to be a dead plant. But, I convince myself, that could happen to anyone. Not everyone has a green thumb.

She pulls out what appears to be a thick binder. She slides it across the desk and motions for me to open it. I am now beginning to think that maybe she is mute, since not a word was spoken. Perhaps I should move my lips very slowly when talking to her so she can read my lips, I think, as I open the binder. There in vivid color are snapshots, photos, 8 x 10 glossies of babies, young adults, black, white, Hispanic, Asian, mentally disabled, physically challenged, older, taller, toddlers, and teenagers. Thirty, forty photos. Some take your breath away. A sparkle in the eyes, a dimple in the cheek, a turned up nose, freckles, thick curly hair, missing teeth, a lazy eye, the gorgeous skin-tone. The sadness is palpable. The joy diminished. The desperation is obvious.

Then she speaks: she tells me it’s a fairly long complicated process, could take weeks and weeks, maybe even a month or two. Yes, yes — bureaucratic bullshit paperwork – my words, not hers. She doesn’t like that I use the word bullshit, I can tell. She continues, a lot of these kids are in homes and are soon to be removed, or have to leave. I ask why. She says well it didn’t work out, there was a clash, the kids, you know, have issues. Major, major issues. The foster parents have issues. Major, major issues. Sometimes there’s no patience or tolerance. Sometimes there are altercations. But they’re getting full up and pretty soon these kids are gonna be back to square one. Her words.

I stare out the window, and think of Ken. He’s probably soaking in a tub, bubble bath and all, watching his beloved Giants, screaming at the TV set, drinking a beer, or glass of Pinot Noir, and enjoying his life completely. Not a care the world. He likes it that way.

I woke up a few days earlier wanting to have a kid, I was hormonal and lonely. Hormonal, lonely and cranky and older than the day before. Not a great combo, I want a kid!!!! Stamping my feet, I’m sure, or the equivalent. Instead of going to the Woodbury Common Outlet stores, I went to Child Services. Instead of trying on a pair of shoes, I looked through a binder of children who needed love, and a home, and a place that was safe and kind and probably, more than likely, never owned a pair of new shoes, because chances are they were all hand-me-downs. And that’s when it all came together. The words: hand-me-downs. I wasn’t making a commitment to giving them a life or a future, I was teetering on making a decision to give them a place to live for a month or two, or maybe even less. In other words, they were returnable. I felt so profoundly sad – my heart breaking. I didn’t want a child for the rest of their life, I wanted a child to take away my loneliness, my crankiness, my hormonal imbalance for a month or two. And it dawned on me in this empty lifeless office with a woman who desperately needed a good haircut and a make-over, that I was being completely and utterly selfish.

I told the Amish slash Mormon woman that I needed some time to think about all of this. I couldn’t be completely truthful with her, and tell her that I had in fact wasted her time, because that would seem even more selfish. She asked me if I wanted to bring the binder home for my husband to look at the photos. I told her, no, and she asked, “Does he like catalogues, because this is just like flipping though a catalogue.”

I stopped feeling selfish in that moment. I looked at her and said: “These kids… in this catalogue, they need love, they need care. They need shoes. They’re not pieces of clothing you pick out, thinking, well if they don’t fit, I can return them, these children on these pages in this binder were not wanted when they came into the world, they’re not returnable. You’re job is to find them a home. A loving home.”

She looked at me, her eyes already filled with sadness, fill up with tears. “I don’t like my job, it’s just I feel so empty.” she said.

We were the same woman in that moment, except I had the better haircut.

“Hey listen,” I say, “I don’t really want a kid, I want to fill a void, and I know what it’s like to feel empty. I do, but while you’re working here, at the very least, please, oh, please … when you hand the person or the couple the binder, please, tell them that the pages are filled with huge potential and an amazing opportunity to love better, love more, and if you don’t wanna do that, maybe you should quit your job and find something you love to do.”

I hit a nerve, I could tell. I hugged her good-bye, a good strong hug. I told her that she should live her life out-loud, that everyone – EVERYONE – is scared, including me, that I was very, very scared; for her to find the thing she loves to do and do it, and … although I thought it, I did not say it: please, I’m begging, go out and get a good haircut, but what I did say was please, please, get rid of the dead plant, it’s not inspiring.

And then the moment of clarity as I drove home. Absolute perfect clarity. I didn’t go there to foster a child, I went there to foster my very own spirit. To awaken to my very own life, to live more fully, to love myself better, to love better period, to stop being so selfish, and to stop thinking I have to — in this moment, right now, this very second – fill a void.

Category: Uncategorized 15 comments »

15 Responses to “non-returnable”

  1. Madge Woods

    Sad but glad you recognized why you had the urge.

  2. kristine

    you have hit a nerve, as you always do. life is so very precious…ours, theirs, his, hers…the moment we have to live and celebrate and choose to extend goodness IS NOW. That is all we have, this moment…

  3. Hollye Dexter

    Oh my god- how have I never read this before? What a gorgeous, funny, brilliant and sad piece. Wow. wow.

    I love you.

  4. melody george

    Oh Amy…I read this and think….maybe you were not there to foster a child…and maybe you were there to foster your own spirit…BUT I think maybe you were there to foster the womans spirit too. Who knows what she did after you left..but maybe..just maybe..she took your words to heart and quit that job and got a new haircut..and found her passion. All because you told her what was in your heart..and what was so obvious to you…and maybe obvious to everyone who met this lady..but MAYBE no one else spoke it out loud.
    There are so many ways to fill a void…and sometimes..just reaching out to a stranger and letting them know you understand how they feel…is one way to do it!
    THIS is why I love you so!

  5. Barbara@The Middle Ages

    Pow. Right in the kisser.

    Voids are inevitable. But often just transient. xo

  6. Cheryl Moseley

    Although I love all of your blogs, this one hit me in a special way. I don’t have children either, but have never had the urge to fill a void. I love your honesty, humor, and kind heart. I agree with Melody, that your REAL mission that day was more than to fill your void. Maybe it was to let her see that her void wasn’t filled either, but that she would have to empty her void before she could be filled.

  7. Judith Newton

    Poignant, funny, complex, and beautifully done.

  8. Kate Hopper

    This is such an amazing post–heartbreaking, funny. You have it all. Thank you!

  9. Hannah Kozak

    So beautiful Amy. I don’t know how this one slipped by. Your compassion moves me straight to the heart chakra. lovelovelove

  10. Hollye Dexter

    And by the way, you ARE a mother and a very nurturing woman. You protect and guide and love and want the best for everyone in your life. Isn’t that what a mother is?

  11. Jas

    Gorgeous. I wish that women all over the world could look inside themselves and recognize that need to fill a void as honestly as you.

    “just like a catalog”

    … Wow.

  12. stacy

    in tears. i love you amy.

  13. Carol

    Oh Amy, you are so amazing!! AMAZING AMY! You always hit me right in the middle of my heart. I have felt the same exact way, even came close to adopting long ago. I have never had a child either and know that space that pops up every once in a while. I had 2 stepdaughters for many years, but they didn’t really need me. I think it’s a feeling of wanted to be needed.
    I’m now marrying Michael and will again be a “Step” Mother. I HATE THAT NAME!!!! Couldn’t they come up with anything better than STEP!!! It sounds like I’m maternally challeneged or something!
    Well, these three almost adult children are fantastic people. So sadly, their Mom passed away when they were little babies and I really feel like they need me. Michael has been an incredible Dad, but their was a definite Mom Void.
    I guess you could say we are filling each other’s voids and for once I truly feel like more than a STEP Mom. I am truly blessed. Thank you for sharing yourself all the time, I love You! This one realllly hit home XOX

  14. Jane

    Beautifully written, as usual.

  15. Krista

    I feel like Hollye and I share a brain. One, I’m thinking, how in the world did I miss this one? I think this may be my very favorite post of yours ever, and that’s a hard decision to come to. And two, right away, I was thinking, not nurturing, who is she kidding? I think you’re very nurturing. In fact, I would argue that you have a very nurturing, loving, warm, maternal spirit and energy that anyone/everyone in your life benefits from. You ooze love and loving kindness. We are all so blessed by that warmth. Excellent post. Love you.

    And it reminds me, damn I need a haircut.

Leave a Reply


Back to top